Get our free one-page cheat sheet of pizzeria cost benchmarks: food, labor, rent and delivery, with a blank for your own numbers.
The industry drowns operators in reports and starves them of decisions. A number only matters if it changes what you do on Monday. Here are the five that do — with the benchmark for each, sourced, so you know what good looks like.
1. Prime cost — the health check
Food plus labor as a share of sales. Quick-service benchmark: 55–60%; Baker Tilly’s QSR dataset says 57.4% (30.5% food, 26.9% labor). Weekly, not monthly — a bad month is four bad weeks you didn’t catch.
2. Food cost variance — the leak detector
The gap between what your menu math says food should cost and what it actually cost. Best-in-class operators hold it to about one percentage point; a 2.5-point gap is real money walking out the back door as over-portioning, waste, and shrink. For scale: Restaurant365 customers eliminated an estimated $318 million in food waste in one year — about 1.2% of food sales.
3. Labor % by daypart — the schedule test
Pizza Today’s 2026 survey puts pizzeria labor at 23–28% of sales. The blended weekly number hides the story: a shop can run 24% overall while burning 40% on dead Tuesday afternoons and understaffing Friday rush. Break it out by daypart and staff to the curve, not to habit. Set a sales-per-labor-hour target per daypart, as Restaurant365 recommends — there’s no universal magic number, but your own trend line is the tell.
4. Online share of sales — the channel mix
Across the industry, ~84% of pizzerias take online orders, averaging 26.9% of sales — and for more than 18% of shops it’s over 45% of revenue. Know your split between first-party (your site, your data, your margin) and third-party (their commission, their customer). The 46% of operators using third-party services average 12.4% of sales there — fine, as long as you’ve priced the channel honestly.
5. Beverage attach — the free margin
Drinks carry 300–500% markups, the best margin in the building. Attach rate — drinks per order — is the cheapest profit lever you have. Veteran operator Joe Farruggio, who targets 3–4% net, reviews profit percentages monthly and adjusts; the discipline matters more than the dashboard.
Free cheat sheet: 15 pizzeria cost benchmarks on one page
Prime cost, labor, delivery and rent, each with its source and a blank for your shop’s number. Enter your email and the download opens right away.
You’ll also get the Oven Scars newsletter. We never sell or share your address.
What this doesn’t cover: speed of service. There’s no honest published benchmark for pies-per-oven-hour or delivery times — the chains stopped publishing theirs. Track your own, week over week. Your baseline is the only one that matters.
